The Stranger

Bobbie

Hank

Isaac

The Radio DJ

Alice

Dutch

Lynn's Mother

Alex Mathis

Carlo (Cop #2)

Mr. Abbadon

Jebediah Rex

Dante

Rusty Rex

Darla (The Witch)

Bart

Detective McNally

Mr. Blake

Lynn

Prof. Milo Gottlieb

Forensic Bob

Mrs. Blake

Sherlock Holmes

Boris

Jack

The Phantom

Adrianne Curry

Maria

Nelson

The Victorian Widow

Parent

Ellen Bishop

Capt. J.G. Zimmerman

Velma

Young Stranger

Kyle (segment "Sweet Tooth")

Lizzy

Background

Todd (segment “The Night Billy Raised Hell”)

Gambling Neighbor

Britney

Lone Child (segment "Ding Dong")

Child Astronaut (segment "Ding Dong")

Child Fireman (segment "Ding Dong") / Kevin (segment "Bad Seed")

Child Jake Gyllenhal (segment "Ding Dong")

Neighbor

Tytan

Mikey (segments "Sweet Tooth" & "Ding Dong"

Alien (segment “The Night Billy Raised Hell”)

Ray Bishop

Timothy Blake

Lt. Brandt-Mathis

Billy (segment "The Night Billy Raised Hell")

Mordecai / The Little Devil (segment "The Night Billy Raised Hell")

The Dentist (segment "The Night Billy Raised Hell")

James (segment "Trick")

Maria (segment "Trick")

Princess (segment "Trick") (as Marnie MckEndry)

Mother (segment "Trick") (as Rebekah MckEndry)

Girl - Witch (segment "Trick" & "Ding Dong")

Alien (segment "Trick") (as Clayton Keller)

"Gypsy" AKA "Cinderella" (segment "Trick")

Devil (segment "Trick") / Devil Girl (segment "Ding Dong")

Little Girl (segment "Trick") (as Bianca Miller)

Mary Bailey (segment "Grim Grinning Ghost")

Mary Bailey (segment "Grim Grinning Ghost")

Baby (segment "Grim Grinning Ghost")

Gretel (segment "Ding Dong")

Lone Child's Mother (segment "Ding Dong")

Witch / Bobbie's Hand / Arm Double (segment "Ding Dong") (as Mo Meinhardt)

Young Alice (segment "The Weak and the Wicked")

The Demon (segment "The Weak and the Wicked")

Ziggy (segment "This Means War")

Axl (segment "This Means War") (as Thomas Blake)

Danzy (segment "This Means War")

Butch (segment "This Means War")

Vicki / Possessed Dorothy (segments "This Means War" & "Friday the 31st")

Goober (segment "This Means War") (as Michael Monterestelli)

Cop / Hellman (segments "This Means War" & "Bad Seed")

Drunken Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Judge Mustache (segment "This Means War")

Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Nosferatu (segment "This Means War")

Detective, Mexican Wrestler (segment "This Means War")

Dorothy (segment "Friday the 31st")

Killer (segment "Friday the 31st")

Coroner #1 (segment "Bad Seed")

Coroner #2 (segment "Bad Seed")

Rembrandt (segment "Bad Seed")

Cheryl (segment "Bad Seed")

Cheerleader Girl (segment "Bad Seed")

Cheerleader Boyfriend (segment "Bad Seed")

Pirate (segment "Bad Seed")

Background

Alien (segment "Ding Dong")

Little Girl's Mom (segment "Ding Dong")

Piggy (segment "The Weak and the Wicked")

Dectective Gemma (The Bad Seed )

Background

Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Parent (segment "Ding Dong")

Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Little Girl (segment "Ding Dong")

Background

Background Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Parent (segment "Ding Dong")

Background

Background

Background

Background

Background

Background (uncredited)

Young Bart (segment "The Weak and the Wicked") (uncredited)